Ann Althouse had someone send in a summary of the presentation. Don't know their position (student, faculty, staff?), but their description certainly sounds far less explosive than what was alleged.
Much like Trayvon Martin. I'm sure that there are other examples.
I'm shocked!!! And now for this amazing late breaking story about fish swimming ...
6/6/13, 5:45 PM
Anonymous said...
their description certainly sounds far less explosive than what was alleged.
Really? What was alleged was as about as "explosive" as a fire-cracker that got left out in a thunder-storm. "She said blacks commit more crime than whites!!! OMG!!"
Like the Richwine witchhunt, what's striking is that what was said to provoke so much faux outrage was so banal.
I interviewed for a federal judicial clerkship with her and also Jerry Smith in Houston back in '98. I was throughly encouraged by a copy of the Bell Curve up on her bookshelf!
In re Amy Wax. She and Glenn Loury debate the black crime problem.
http://bloggingheads.tv/videos/2752
6/7/13, 5:56 AM
Rohan Swee said...
I second Geoff Matthews recommendation of the attendee's summary over at the Althouse blog. Pretty much confirms what I suspected about the allegations of racism and religious nuttery. (The latter of which I noticed some iStevers, who should know better, were willing to accept on faith.)
It would be unfortunate if she didn't say the things of which she is "accused". Since they are true statements, her the finding that "she didn't actually say Those Things" as the basis of her "acquittal" carries with it the subtext that she should she have said "Those Things" she should have not been "acquitted".
6/7/13, 12:20 PM
Svigor said...
I was at the speech. Unfortunately, she actually didn't say half the things she is accused of saying. No one there seemed particularly shocked.
Funny, I typed up a response to the first Judge Edith thread, but never posted it. The gist was that there's no point to this without a recording of some kind, because the Judge would manhandle her accusers in court without one, and eyewitness' recall of things with thought-warping taboo effect fields around them has roughly zero credibility.
6/7/13, 5:38 PM
Anonymous said...
Her comment that Hispanics are prone to commit more crimes is an example of stereotypes making your stupider.
Unz has proven Hispanics don't commit more crime than whites. They are just younger than whites so that's why there's more Hispanic crime not because they are prone to it.
6/7/13, 11:55 PM
Svigor said...
Her comment that Hispanics are prone to commit more crimes is an example of stereotypes making your stupider.
Unz has proven Hispanics don't commit more crime than whites. They are just younger than whites so that's why there's more Hispanic crime not because they are prone to it.
Right. Blacks aren't more prone to crime. They're just more prone to poverty. It's poor people who are more prone to crime.
6/8/13, 7:41 AM
A friend writes:
I was at the speech. Unfortunately, she actually didn't say half the things she is accused of saying. No one there seemed particularly shocked.
"More on Judge Edith Jones"
16 Comments -
The "friend" absolutely has to be Amy Wax, doesn't it?
6/6/13, 3:08 PM
I don't know Amy Wax.
6/6/13, 3:30 PM
Ann Althouse had someone send in a summary of the presentation. Don't know their position (student, faculty, staff?), but their description certainly sounds far less explosive than what was alleged.
Much like Trayvon Martin. I'm sure that there are other examples.
http://www.althouse.blogspot.com/2013/06/frankly-whenever-i-see-complaint.html#more
6/6/13, 3:35 PM
"I don't know Amy Wax."
Darn, I figured between it being Penn Law and you being only one degree of separation away via Derbyshire:
http://www.johnderbyshire.com/Opinions/HumanSciences/upennlaw.html
6/6/13, 5:10 PM
Lefties lying?
I'm shocked!!! And now for this amazing late breaking story about fish swimming ...
6/6/13, 5:45 PM
their description certainly sounds far less explosive than what was alleged.
Really? What was alleged was as about as "explosive" as a fire-cracker that got left out in a thunder-storm. "She said blacks commit more crime than whites!!! OMG!!"
Like the Richwine witchhunt, what's striking is that what was said to provoke so much faux outrage was so banal.
6/6/13, 5:55 PM
I interviewed for a federal judicial clerkship with her and also Jerry Smith in Houston back in '98. I was throughly encouraged by a copy of the Bell Curve up on her bookshelf!
6/6/13, 6:03 PM
Steve:
You don't know Amy Wax? Really?
Get acquainted.
6/7/13, 2:06 AM
Steve:
You don't know Amy Wax? Really?
Get acquainted.
6/7/13, 2:07 AM
holy shit, the derb himself?
6/7/13, 5:38 AM
In re Amy Wax. She and Glenn Loury debate the black crime problem.
http://bloggingheads.tv/videos/2752
6/7/13, 5:56 AM
I second Geoff Matthews recommendation of the attendee's summary over at the Althouse blog. Pretty much confirms what I suspected about the allegations of racism and religious nuttery. (The latter of which I noticed some iStevers, who should know better, were willing to accept on faith.)
6/7/13, 6:31 AM
It would be unfortunate if she didn't say the things of which she is "accused". Since they are true statements, her the finding that "she didn't actually say Those Things" as the basis of her "acquittal" carries with it the subtext that she should she have said "Those Things" she should have not been "acquitted".
6/7/13, 12:20 PM
I was at the speech. Unfortunately, she actually didn't say half the things she is accused of saying. No one there seemed particularly shocked.
Funny, I typed up a response to the first Judge Edith thread, but never posted it. The gist was that there's no point to this without a recording of some kind, because the Judge would manhandle her accusers in court without one, and eyewitness' recall of things with thought-warping taboo effect fields around them has roughly zero credibility.
6/7/13, 5:38 PM
Her comment that Hispanics are prone to commit more crimes is an example of stereotypes making your stupider.
Unz has proven Hispanics don't commit more crime than whites. They are just younger than whites so that's why there's more Hispanic crime not because they are prone to it.
6/7/13, 11:55 PM
Her comment that Hispanics are prone to commit more crimes is an example of stereotypes making your stupider.
Unz has proven Hispanics don't commit more crime than whites. They are just younger than whites so that's why there's more Hispanic crime not because they are prone to it.
Right. Blacks aren't more prone to crime. They're just more prone to poverty. It's poor people who are more prone to crime.
6/8/13, 7:41 AM