Hahah - yeah a rawther lackluster but predictable set, I was actually surprised they didn't nominate 'The Book Thief' since it's got all the ingredients Oscar loves. As for Llewyn, my guess is they either didn't see it (did they not get screeners?) and/or they don't vote for films where the lead is a jerk, because they're worried their nephews will think its okay to start being surly... or maybe they're still squirming under the yoke of the now long gone production code's moral edicts?
Very entertaining post. I guessed you liked "Inside Llewyn Davis," huh? "-) Seriously, the Academy has shown a lot of love toward the Coens, so the overall lack of nominations was a bit of a surprise.
How about Thelma Schoonmaker not getting a Best Editing nomination for "Wolf of Wall Street"? To me, this was a bit of a shock, especially as she's won three Oscars in this category and she received so much praise for her work with this film, trimming it down from four hours to three.
I'm a bit surprised at the lack of nominations for "Saving Mr. Banks." Did the Academy think that by honoring this film, it would have been too much of a inside pat on the back for Disney? Whatever you thought of the film - I loved it and I know you admired it as well - it is a marvelous technical work, so this could have easily been nominated for Best Editing - it certainly deserved that over "Dallas Buyers Club" in this category.
One question - why do you believe that Bruce Dern should have been a Supporting Actor nominee? This is a leading performance, it is not? I do agree with you that Robert Redford should have been nominated for Best Actor.
I saw Gravity, I liked Gravity, I just feel that it was overrated, so I see it not winning a whole lot (ditto for Her), maybe Cinematography. I think your political orientation is coloring your view of Captain Philips. Read your review, saw it a few weeks later, completely disagreed with your takes. Would have liked to see Hanks nominated, but probably can't bump any of the actual nominees either. We do agree on Inside Llewyn Davies. An odd movie but for some reason also my favorite of the year.
Erich, I'm actually surprised at how unconventional the Academy went this year. They could have gone and made it strictly an AMERICAN HUSTLE or 12 YEARS sweep this year, going with a popular/art schism, shut everyone else out, and most of us would have done the typical bitch-and-moan, "I'm not that surprised" schtick we usually do, end of story.
The very fact that THE WOLF OF WALL STREET had such a respectable showing, despite its flagrant irreverence in an Oscar sense, is one reason I don't necessarily agree with your take on it. After all, its lead is a major league, surly jerk.
Tom, here's why I believe Schoonmaker didn't get the nod this year. TWOWS was rushed out to theaters, through no fault of hers. If there's one problem I had with that glorious movie, it's that it still feels too fat/the pacing is off. Another 2 months, and I think it could have baked up perfectly. As it is, I'm kind of glad we got the shaggy mess we did.
SAVING MR. BANKS is just contaminated now by all of the backlash "Uncle Walt" got from so many now in positions of power in Hollywood. I mean, you know some of that fear of Disney (the man and the organization) has diminished when Streep can rip into him the way she did without fear of reprisal (she's cast as the Witch in Disney's upcoming adaptation of Sondheim's INTO THE WOODS).
As for Dern, though he plays a substantial part in NEBRASKA I still believe it is a supporting part. I always view the protagonist as the person who undergoes a change because of the story. While he certainly experienced a journey of sorts, it is Will Forte that is changed by the experience. Dern is essentially the same cranky but blissed out soul he was at the end of the picture as he was at the start. His role was supporting that of Forte. Screen time is not the measuring stick for me is what I'm saying.
Patrick, I can't entirely dismiss your theory as to why CAPTAIN PHILLIPS fell flat for me. After all, I was going to defend myself with how inaccurate the story was in the movie, favoring Phillips despite the fact that many of his crew blame him for recklessly travelling through the dangerous area in the first place.
But then, the considerable inaccuracies of SAVING MR. BANKS didn't bother me one whit. So touché.
I saw a few contradictory comments from crew members on the accuracy of Captain Philips, so that did cause me to hold back from it just a bit.
January 19, 2014 at 4:01 PM
by Tony Dayoub
[Image]
The Dayoub household is under a flu quarantine of sorts, so it was hard to muster any kind of my usual enthusiasm for the Oscar nominations announcement this morning as I lay watching them from my sickbed. But here's the most complete list of nominees I could find. I'll chime in with my thoughts as necessary (in italics), primarily in the form of pointing out any major snubs. Highlighted in red are the nominees I'm rooting for, not my predictions. I know there are many who try to predict Oscar winners, but this way lies madness, in my humble opinion. Feel free to leave your thoughts or tell me who you're rooting for in the comments section.
Here's the list of nominees, all in all, not a bad one in this very competitive year:
Best Picture
12 Years a Slave American Hustle
Captain Phillips
Dallas Buyers Club
Gravity
Her
Nebraska
Philomena
The Wolf of Wall Street
It's nice to see that despite all of the quite pointless controversy and the lateness of its release for consideration, The Wolf of Wall Street is acknowledged here and throughout many other categories. But what is Captain Phillips doing here? And with this category allowed up to 10 nominations, why ignore Inside Llewyn Davis, which was virtually ignored by the Academy in all but the most minor categories?
Best Director
David O. Russell, American Hustle
Alfonso Cuarón, Gravity
Alexander Payne, Nebraska Steve McQueen, 12 Years a Slave
Martin Scorsese, The Wolf of Wall Street
Again, the Coen Brothers were snubbed for the sublime Inside Llewyn Davis. I'll stop soon.
Best Actor
Christian Bale, American Hustle
Bruce Dern, Nebraska Leonardo DiCaprio, The Wolf of Wall Street
Chiwetel Ejiofor, 12 Years a Slave
Matthew McConaughey, Dallas Buyers Club
It's tough to say anyone here was undeserving. But Oscar Isaac was superb as the title character of (all together now) Inside Llewyn Davis. And his performance in Her was among Joaquin Phoenix's very best if least showy. Bruce Dern should actually have been nominated for supporting actor which would have opened the venerable-seventies-actor slot for the snubbed Robert Redford of All is Lost.
Best Actress
Amy Adams, American Hustle
Cate Blanchett, Blue Jasmine
Sandra Bullock, Gravity
Judi Dench, Philomena
Meryl Streep, August: Osage County
No Emma Thompson (Saving Mr. Banks)? Maybe Meryl's recent speech at the National Board of Review dinner, decrying the rehabilitation of Uncle Walt's more distasteful qualities, helped open Thompson's slot for her instead. I'm elated that Amy Adams rates a nomination since this is her career best performance in a role that represents American Hustle's heart. Cate Blanchett is the favorite, but I wouldn't be too surprised if Adams wins.
[Image] Best Original Screenplay
American Hustle – Written by Eric Warren Singer and David O. Russell Blue Jasmine – Written by Woody Allen Her – Written by Spike Jonze Nebraska – Written by Bob Nelson Dallas Buyers Club – Written by Craig Borten & Melisa Wallack
Seriously, can you get more original than Her, about a man that falls in love with his operating system?
Best Adapted Screenplay
Before Midnight – Written by Richard Linklater, Julie Delpy, Ethan Hawke Captain Phillips – Screenplay by Billy Ray Philomena – Screenplay by Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope 12 Years a Slave – Screenplay by John Ridley The Wolf of Wall Street – Screenplay by Terence Winter
Still find it surprising that Captain Phillips got so much love.
Best Supporting Actress
Lupita Nyong’o, 12 Years a Slave
Jennifer Lawrence, American Hustle
June Squibb, Nebraska
Julia Roberts, August: Osage County
Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
I'm hoping a simple acknowledgement is all that current it-girl Jennifer Lawrence receives because Lupita Nyong'o is considerably more deserving. Was anyone else surprised that Oprah wasn't nominated for Lee Daniels' The Butler? Meh... me neither.
Best Supporting Actor
Barkhad Abdi, Captain Phillips
Bradley Cooper, American Hustle Michael Fassbender, 12 Years a Slave
Jonah Hill, The Wolf of Wall Street
Jared Leto, Dallas Buyers Club
A fairly predictable set of nominees, and I'll be surprised if anyone but Jared Leto gets the Oscar. Still, it would have been nice to see James Gandolfini get a posthumous nod for his understated performance in Enough Said.
Best Animated Film
The Croods
Despicable Me 2
Ernest & Celestine Frozen The Wind Rises
What's most notable here is that this is the first time a Pixar movie, in this case Monsters University (which wasn't bad, but...), isn't nominated. Hopefully it will serve as a wake-up call for the creatively troubled animation facility.
Best Documentary Feature
The Act of Killing Joshua Oppenheimer and Signe Byrge Sørensen Cutie and the Boxer Zachary Heinzerling and Lydia Dean Pilcher Dirty Wars Richard Rowley and Jeremy Scahill The Square Jehane Noujaim and Karim Amer 20 Feet from Stardom Nominees to be determined
All of these were on my list of 2013's top docs, save for The Square which I have yet to see (but I understand it deserves its nomination). One glaring omission though is Blackfish, the Sea World exposé.
[Image]
The rest:
Best Cinematography
The Grandmaster
Gravity Inside Llewyn Davis Nebraska
Prisoners
Best Costume Design
Michael Wilkinson, American Hustle
William Chang Suk Ping, The Grandmaster Catherine Martin, The Great Gatsby
Michael O’Connor, The Invisible Woman
Patricia Norris, 12 Years a Slave
Best Documentary Short Subject
CaveDigger Jeffrey Karoff Facing Fear Jason Cohen Karama Has No Walls Sara Ishaq The Lady in Number 6: Music Saved My Life Malcolm Clarke and Nicholas Reed Prison Terminal: The Last Days of Private Jack Hall Edgar Barens
Best Film Editing
American Hustle Jay Cassidy, Crispin Struthers and Alan Baumgarten Captain Phillips Christopher Rouse Dallas Buyers Club John Mac McMurphy and Martin Pensa Gravity Alfonso Cuarón and Mark Sanger 12 Years a Slave Joe Walker
Best Foreign Language Film
The Broken Circle Breakdown Belgium The Great Beauty Italy The Hunt Denmark The Missing Picture Cambodia Omar Palestine
Best Makeup and Hairstyling
Dallas Buyers Club Adruitha Lee and Robin Mathews Jackass Presents: Bad Grandpa Stephen Prouty The Lone Ranger Joel Harlow and Gloria Pasqua-Casny
Best Original Score
John Williams, The Book Thief
Steven Price, Gravity William Butler and Owen Pallett, Her
Alexandre Desplat, Philomena
Thomas Newman, Saving Mr. Banks
Best Original Song
"Alone Yet Not Alone" from Alone Yet Not Alone
Music by Bruce Broughton; Lyric by Dennis Spiegel
"Happy" from Despicable Me 2
Music and Lyric by Pharrell Williams
"Let It Go" from Frozen
Music and Lyric by Kristen Anderson-Lopez and Robert Lopez
"The Moon Song" from Her
Music by Karen O; Lyric by Karen O and Spike Jonze
"Ordinary Love" from Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom
Music by Paul Hewson, Dave Evans, Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen; Lyric by Paul Hewson
Best Production Design
American Hustle
Production Design: Judy Becker; Set Decoration: Heather Loeffler
Gravity
Production Design: Andy Nicholson; Set Decoration: Rosie Goodwin and Joanne Woollard
The Great Gatsby
Production Design: Catherine Martin; Set Decoration: Beverley Dunn
Her Production Design: K.K. Barrett; Set Decoration: Gene Serdena
12 Years a Slave
Production Design: Adam Stockhausen; Set Decoration: Alice Baker
Best Animated Short Film
Feral Daniel Sousa and Dan Golden Get a Horse! Lauren MacMullan and Dorothy McKim Mr. Hublot Laurent Witz and Alexandre Espigares Possessions Shuhei Morita Room on the Broom Max Lang and Jan Lachauer
Best Live Action Short Film
Aquel No Era Yo (That Wasn’t Me) Esteban Crespo Avant Que De Tout Perdre (Just Before Losing Everything) Xavier Legrand and Alexandre Gavras Helium Anders Walter and Kim Magnusson Pitääkö Mun Kaikki Hoitaa? (Do I Have to Take Care of Everything?) Selma Vilhunen and Kirsikka Saari The Voorman Problem Mark Gill and Baldwin Li
Best Sound Editing
All Is Lost Steve Boeddeker and Richard Hymns Captain Phillips Oliver Tarney Gravity Glenn Freemantle The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Brent Burge Lone Survivor Wylie Stateman
Best Sound Mixing
Captain Phillips Chris Burdon, Mark Taylor, Mike Prestwood Smith and Chris Munro Gravity Skip Lievsay, Niv Adiri, Christopher Benstead and Chris Munro The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Christopher Boyes, Michael Hedges, Michael Semanick and Tony Johnson Inside Llewyn Davis Skip Lievsay, Greg Orloff and Peter F. Kurland Lone Survivor Andy Koyama, Beau Borders and David Brownlow
Best Visual Effects
Gravity Tim Webber, Chris Lawrence, Dave Shirk and Neil Corbould The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Joe Letteri, Eric Saindon, David Clayton and Eric Reynolds Iron Man 3 Christopher Townsend, Guy Williams, Erik Nash and Dan Sudick The Lone Ranger Tim Alexander, Gary Brozenich, Edson Williams and John Frazier Star Trek Into Darkness Roger Guyett, Patrick Tubach, Ben Grossmann and Burt Dalton
"Nominations for the 86th Academy Awards (and Brief Analysis)"
7 Comments -
Hahah - yeah a rawther lackluster but predictable set, I was actually surprised they didn't nominate 'The Book Thief' since it's got all the ingredients Oscar loves. As for Llewyn, my guess is they either didn't see it (did they not get screeners?) and/or they don't vote for films where the lead is a jerk, because they're worried their nephews will think its okay to start being surly... or maybe they're still squirming under the yoke of the now long gone production code's moral edicts?
January 16, 2014 at 4:12 PM
Tony:
Very entertaining post. I guessed you liked "Inside Llewyn Davis," huh? "-) Seriously, the Academy has shown a lot of love toward the Coens, so the overall lack of nominations was a bit of a surprise.
How about Thelma Schoonmaker not getting a Best Editing nomination for "Wolf of Wall Street"? To me, this was a bit of a shock, especially as she's won three Oscars in this category and she received so much praise for her work with this film, trimming it down from four hours to three.
I'm a bit surprised at the lack of nominations for "Saving Mr. Banks." Did the Academy think that by honoring this film, it would have been too much of a inside pat on the back for Disney? Whatever you thought of the film - I loved it and I know you admired it as well - it is a marvelous technical work, so this could have easily been nominated for Best Editing - it certainly deserved that over "Dallas Buyers Club" in this category.
One question - why do you believe that Bruce Dern should have been a Supporting Actor nominee? This is a leading performance, it is not? I do agree with you that Robert Redford should have been nominated for Best Actor.
January 18, 2014 at 1:51 PM
I saw Gravity, I liked Gravity, I just feel that it was overrated, so I see it not winning a whole lot (ditto for Her), maybe Cinematography. I think your political orientation is coloring your view of Captain Philips. Read your review, saw it a few weeks later, completely disagreed with your takes. Would have liked to see Hanks nominated, but probably can't bump any of the actual nominees either. We do agree on Inside Llewyn Davies. An odd movie but for some reason also my favorite of the year.
January 18, 2014 at 3:46 PM
Erich, I'm actually surprised at how unconventional the Academy went this year. They could have gone and made it strictly an AMERICAN HUSTLE or 12 YEARS sweep this year, going with a popular/art schism, shut everyone else out, and most of us would have done the typical bitch-and-moan, "I'm not that surprised" schtick we usually do, end of story.
The very fact that THE WOLF OF WALL STREET had such a respectable showing, despite its flagrant irreverence in an Oscar sense, is one reason I don't necessarily agree with your take on it. After all, its lead is a major league, surly jerk.
January 18, 2014 at 4:18 PM
Tom, here's why I believe Schoonmaker didn't get the nod this year. TWOWS was rushed out to theaters, through no fault of hers. If there's one problem I had with that glorious movie, it's that it still feels too fat/the pacing is off. Another 2 months, and I think it could have baked up perfectly. As it is, I'm kind of glad we got the shaggy mess we did.
SAVING MR. BANKS is just contaminated now by all of the backlash "Uncle Walt" got from so many now in positions of power in Hollywood. I mean, you know some of that fear of Disney (the man and the organization) has diminished when Streep can rip into him the way she did without fear of reprisal (she's cast as the Witch in Disney's upcoming adaptation of Sondheim's INTO THE WOODS).
As for Dern, though he plays a substantial part in NEBRASKA I still believe it is a supporting part. I always view the protagonist as the person who undergoes a change because of the story. While he certainly experienced a journey of sorts, it is Will Forte that is changed by the experience. Dern is essentially the same cranky but blissed out soul he was at the end of the picture as he was at the start. His role was supporting that of Forte. Screen time is not the measuring stick for me is what I'm saying.
January 18, 2014 at 4:29 PM
Patrick, I can't entirely dismiss your theory as to why CAPTAIN PHILLIPS fell flat for me. After all, I was going to defend myself with how inaccurate the story was in the movie, favoring Phillips despite the fact that many of his crew blame him for recklessly travelling through the dangerous area in the first place.
But then, the considerable inaccuracies of SAVING MR. BANKS didn't bother me one whit. So touché.
January 18, 2014 at 4:36 PM
I saw a few contradictory comments from crew members on the accuracy of Captain Philips, so that did cause me to hold back from it just a bit.
January 19, 2014 at 4:01 PM