Google apps
Main menu

Post a Comment On: Fawcett Avenue Conscripts

"40K - A Matter of Scale"

8 Comments -

1 – 8 of 8
Blogger Muskie said...

I totally agree about 40K scale being way off. It used to be you could run as far in say 15 seconds as you could should an automatic submachine gun.

This problem isn't unique to 5th edition, when I first started playing in the early 90s people would get mad at me for not gluing together all my orks and gretchin so they could field more of their army and kill more of mine. People want to pile all their toys on the table, even unpainted toys. Hence Apocolypse scale games.

I've yet to play in an Apoclypse scale game though like a lot of things I bought the rule book when I should have been studying something else. I also stick to only fielding painted models and only assembling models I plan to paint. Hordes of unpainted or even partially speed painted models don't appeal to me much.

I think things get particularly out of whack at some tournaments down South where 2500 points is crammed onto a 6*4 foot table with medium terrain. Hence why reserving your entire force and skipping a turn or two of game play is such a popular tactic now. We used to play on 8*4 tables or bigger back in the day we also used to play lengthwise in Rogue Trader era. Now obviously bigger tables isn't possible for a lot of people due to cost and space restrictions, which is why I wish skirmish sized games were more popular. I'm going to have to run a skirmish sized campaign again someday. But I'm not in a position to do so and don't know when I'll be...

I personally also often enforce additional army choice restrictions on myself besides the obvious must be fully painted and WYSIWYG. I'm curious to see what 6th edition and new Chaos rules in particular brings. I haven't played in over a year, if too much more time goes passed, maybe I'll never get back into the game...

March 10, 2012 at 1:18 PM

Blogger MrLee said...

Great set of battle reps there, and comments on the scale of 40k also.

Haven't been playing it for a while due to the SM spam that happens in my local area, but even if I did I can't see my Orks doing so well with them all huddled up together on the table. Just screams template spam against me, and then its no longer fun.

Great looking armies that you got to play with/against. Makes me want to get back to painting mine up and maybe even playing again, but in smaller games obviously. :)

March 11, 2012 at 5:00 AM

Blogger DaveV said...

Muskie, I don`t mind the odd WIP fig, but I very much prefer to play against fully painted armies. Seeing hordes of Casper Legions (i.e. unpainted figs) kind of ruins some Apocalypse events for me. These days, I also won`t field unpainted miodels. Takes me out of the game, so to speak.

I remember playing lots of 40K on a 9 foot by 5 foot ping pong table packed with terrain. A couple of times we also eplayed West End`s Star Wars Miniatures Battles with only 7 good guy heroes on such a table, representing Mos Eisly space port.

Mr. Lee, even Kill Team (200 pt forces from the Battle Missions book) and Combat Patrol (500 pt forces) havde a lot of scope for interesting 40K games. At 1000 points you basically have a reinforced section or light platoon, which IMO is much easier to manage than the company-sized engagements you often see now.

We are spoil in Winnipeg. There`s a lot ofpeople with beautiful armies around here.

March 11, 2012 at 11:32 AM

Blogger Jim Hounslow said...

cempage CallitDave,

Having played both 40K and FoW, I'm in complete agreement with both linked articles.

But I'd actually go a bit further and say that FoW's ground scale is too short , at times, even FoW feels 15mm minis feel too large on the table. I often wonder if the game would be better suited to 10mm or even 6mm.

28mm works better as a skirmish system with platoon size or smaller units.

Warhammer has gotten ridiculous. 8th ed requires even more minis in larger units. I'm slowly bulking mine up from 7th ed.

I play Rules of Engagement (RoE); WWII platoon level + support skirmish. I have a German grenadier platoon with 30 grenadiers, a command unit of 6, two HMGs and a mortar squad; 45 minis in total.

I like both scales: the size and detail of 28mm mini, and the mass of minis in 15mm.

In terms of rules, I prefer FoW for the reasons covered in the article. It's also easier, quicker and cheaper to buy, build and paint a company in 15mm than 28mm for 40K.

Jim

March 11, 2012 at 7:08 PM

Blogger Greg B said...

Neat post Dave. Thanks for the links to those articles. I would suggest the problems in 40k go much beyond the scale of the game. Even a smaller 40k games still leaves an unsatisfied feeling, because the core mechanics are simply off. Flames of War is somewhat better, but only in a relative sense - almost any other rules I try for skirmish and for company-level gaming are superior to both. FOW is just a little further back in the degradation curve.

March 11, 2012 at 7:45 PM

Blogger DaveV said...

Jim, I picked up the FoW 3rd ed. rulebook. I like what I've read so far. One thing I really like about FoW is how tank crews can be caused to bail out. You read and hear historical accounts of this a lot.

Greg, I love the 40K background, which keeps me in the game despite the rules. SJG did a very clean set of skirmish battle armour rules almost 30 years ago called Battlesuit. One die roll to get hit, damage and morale effect. I've been looking at DriveThruRPG and Wargame Vault, seeking alternative rules to do Colonial Marines vs. Aliens vs. Predators.

March 11, 2012 at 9:33 PM

Blogger JP40kegger said...

Thanks for using the 40kegger missions in such a wonderful study of 40k scale. I really think that 1000 point games are overseen in the 40k community, so it's nice to see some support.

I really havn't explored the world of tabletops outside of 40k. Like you, I am hooked on the background quite intensely.

Looking forward to starting Malifaux which seems like a great gang-sized skirmish game.

March 12, 2012 at 3:38 PM

Blogger DaveV said...

J.P., I did just pick up the Rasputina faction for Malifaux. Don't know when I'll be able to get to them, since I want to concentrate on Aliens v. Predator universe and Heroic Age Greece skirmish stuff as my non-40K vices this year.

Thanks for getting me into 40Kegger. The smaller armies have gotten me very interested in mixing up my Eldar (I usually run only one list during any particular tournament season), as well as working again on other factions. Besides starting up again on my Crimson Fists I just put together the last models for a 1K Imperial Guard list - 53 troops, two tanks and a Hades Breaching drill.

March 12, 2012 at 8:08 PM

You can use some HTML tags, such as <b>, <i>, <a>

Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author.

You will be asked to sign in after submitting your comment.