Post a Comment On: The SkywalkerSwartz Blog

I did some more research into the debate over tax policy and small businesses, and found a number of sources (including BusinessWeek) citing a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report by Dr. Jane G. Gravelle, an economist who specializes in tax policy.

The report's title is "Small Business and the Expiration of the 2001 Tax Rate Reductions: Economic Issues," (CRS Report R41392, released Sept. 3, 2010).  While another report ("Bush Tax Cuts and the Economy" by Thomas L. Hungerford) released on the same day is available on the web thanks to the Federation of American Scientists, I could not find Dr. Gravelle's report anywhere.  What gives?  It turns out that all Congressional Research Service reports are secret--by department policy.  Can you imagine that?  Taxpayers have no access to reports by Congress's main policy analysts.

While the CRS claims that this policy maintains their confidential relationship with Congress and prevents diverting resources to answering public questions, these arguments are preposterous:

The other Congressional research arms such as the Congressional Budget Office and Government Accountability Office offer their reports online, yet they are still respected as independent policy analysts. Nearly all CRS reports are already available online--for a price--from such groups as Penny Hill Press, CQ-Roll Call, Lexis Nexis, and the Bureau of National Affairs.  So much for confidentiality.  Putting reports on a government website would merely mean that all the public would have access, not just the elite. Just because reports are available to the public doesn't mean that the CRS has to respond (directly) to public inquiries--CRS would still work for Congress.  Indeed, House of Representatives General Counsel Stan Brand already dismissed CRS's concerns as "overstated" at best. While every good government group supports opening CRS reports to the public, for some reason legislation to do just that has stalled year after year.  In this Congress, House Resolution 3762 and Senate  Resolution 118 are stuck in the House Administration and Senate Rules & Administration Committees, respectively.  Contact committee members and ask them to support open, transparent government by opening up CRS reports to the public who paid for them:

House Administration Committee Members (also see contactingthecongress and congress.org) Robert Brady (D-PA1, Chair), 215-389-4627, 202-225-4731 Zoe Lofgren, (D-CA16, Vice-Chair), 408-271-8700, 202-225-3072 Michael Capuano (D-MA8), 617-621-6208, 202-225-9322 Charles Gonzalez (D-TX20), 210-472-6195, 202-225-3236 Susan Davis (D-CA53), 619-280-5353, 202-225-2040 Artur Davis (D-AL7), 205-254-1960, 202-225-2665 Dan Lungren (R-CA3, Ranking Member), 916-859-9906, 202-225-5716 Kevin McCarthy (R-CA22), 661-327-3611, 202-225-2915 Gregg Harper (R-MS3), 601-932-2410, 202-225-5031 Senate Rules and Administration Committee Members (also see contactingthecongress and congress.org) Chuck Schumer (D-NY, Chair), 212-486-4430, 202-224-6542 Dan Inouye (D-HI), 808-541-2542, 202-224-3934 Chris Dodd (D-CT), 860-258-6940, 202-224-2823 Diane Feinstein (D-CA), 415-393-0707, 202-224-3841 Dick Durbin (D-IL), 312-353-4952, 202-224-2152 Ben Nelson (D-NE), 402-391-3411, 202-224-6551 Patty Murray (D-WA), 206-553-5545, 202-224-2621 Mark Pryor (D-AR), 501-324-6336, 202-224-2353 Tom Udall (D-NM), 505-346-6791, 202-224-6621 Mark Warner (D-VA), 804-775-2314, 202-224-2023 Bob Bennett (R-UT, Ranking Member), 801-524-5933, 202-224-5444 Mitch McConnell (R-KY), 502-582-6304, 202-224-2541 Thad Cochran (R-MS), 601-965-4459, 202-224-5054 Kay Bailey Hutchinson (R-TX), 512-916-5834, 202-224-5922 Saxby Chambliss (R-GA), 800-234-4208, 202-224-3521 Lamar Alexander (R-TN), 901-544-4224, 202-224-4944 John Ensign (R-NV), 702-388-6605, 202-224-6244 Pat Roberts (R-KS), 785-295-2745, 202-224-4774
For more information on why CRS reports aren't available on the web, a New York Times article, the Wikipedia article on CRS report confidentiality, and an LLRX paper have more detail.

Update: Success!  I finally got a copy of CRS Report 41392, which is now available on OpenCRS.  The trick is to keep calling your Representative/Senators' offices until they email it to you.  But the real battle (for making all reports available) is still ahead...