Comments on Thanks for the Use of the Hall: 2007 Lists

I think that "Away from Her" is a lovely and subtl...

2008-02-12T17:42:00.000-05:00

I think that "Away from Her" is a lovely and subtle film, and a very good adaptation of the Alice Munro short story. Gordon Pinsent is especially in the role of the husband Grant.
Peter

Yeah, Naranjo is a double threat: good dialogue an...

2008-01-24T14:56:00.000-05:00

Yeah, Naranjo is a double threat: good dialogue and a good eye. In September, Variety wrote, "Canana (a production company) is currently filming Gerardo Naranjo's third feature, Voy a explotar, which follows two 15-year-olds on a romantic lark in Guanajuato."

I am glad you mention drama/mex. My favorite movie...

2008-01-23T13:38:00.000-05:00

I am glad you mention drama/mex. My favorite movie last year but one that seems out of every critic´s radar

'cita - I know you like DVD, but if you want to ge...

2008-01-08T12:33:00.000-05:00

'cita - I know you like DVD, but if you want to get theatrical, Lady Chatterley will be screening at MOMA on Monday, January 28 (with the director in attendance) and on Thursday, February 7.

I thought Away from Her was awful--just leaden and...

2008-01-07T13:31:00.000-05:00

I thought Away from Her was awful--just leaden and tonedeaf and too many shots of Julie Christie in really amazing sweaters, which seemed incongruous with her mental state.

I have Netflixed Hannah Takes the Stairs and Lady Chatterley.

Jonah - yeah, Ms. Polley's film seemed like a bit ...

2008-01-06T10:37:00.000-05:00

Jonah - yeah, Ms. Polley's film seemed like a bit of a waxworks to me: heavy performance style, obvious visual and narrative intent. I must confess that I didn't stick it out: The Thing from Another World was playing somewhere later that night, and I hadn't seen it in 20 years or so, and it just didn't seem fair somehow.

But people whose judgment I respect admire Away from Her. After 35 years of serious filmgoing, I understand less than ever how my tastes fit into the population of all tastes. I feel a great, existentialist solitude in the realm of art preferences - they feel so objective! - and I still don't understand why everyone doesn't seem to feel this solitude.

I'm glad there is another dissenter on "Away from ...

2008-01-06T02:19:00.000-05:00

I'm glad there is another dissenter on "Away from Her." The formal choices Polley made frequently felt banal. Shot/reverse shot rhythms felt mechanical, uninspired, and when she altered the rhythm to highlight a moment it always felt too deliberate. I could anticipate shot changes, changes in scale, etc. in a way that wasn't pleasant for me.

When Polley seemed unsure of what impact a scene should have on the overall narrative, she added a little coda of "tasteful" pictorial effects (overexposure, slomo, soft focus). And the characterizations felt quite pat--their arcs seemed too clean.

I'm probably being overly negative. That's my contrarian impulse. But I left the movie feeling that anything with such a weighty subject should have shaken me up rather than alienated me as it did.

Sadly, because I don't live in a major market, I've only been able to see three of the films on your top 9 list (#s 2-4).

Eric - thanks for the correction on the Rodriguez....

2008-01-05T11:07:00.000-05:00

Eric - thanks for the correction on the Rodriguez. I did see your lists, which were interesting, a bit more varied than most. If I got upset at seeing lists I didn't agree with, I wouldn't be able to get out of the fetal position this time of year....

A lot of people seem to be down on Hannah - I don't get it. I thought it would get more year-end attention than it has. I haven't read Amy Taubin's attack in Film Comment, but a lot of people, pro and con, seem to be citing it, so maybe it was influential. Anyway, the world is not overcrowded with filmmakers who can show the appealing and uncomfortable aspects of people as part of the same fluid personality system; and America even less so.

I debated about leaving a comment, because there i...

2008-01-05T04:47:00.000-05:00

I debated about leaving a comment, because there is no way I can just focus on just one thing here-so bear with me.

You may have been my ten list on my blog-if not, it's there right now. I've only seen five of the films in your top nine-Lady Chatterley being my persona favorite out of those. I still think Darjeeling was a lesser Anderson, good nonetheless, but nothing too amazing. Stephanie Daley and Day Night Day Night I both liked, but Hannah Takes the Stairs I almost detested. I am really having a hard time getting into that whole "mumblecore" movement-and when I saw Funny Ha Ha two years ago I was still left scratching my head.

You seem to like We Own the Night way more than I could even consider.

I like how you mention Fay Grim with something positive next to it. Although very different from Henry Fool, I still really enjoyed. it. I loved The Bothersome Man, and Red Road, and kind of forgot about White Palms-I caught that at MOMA sometime over the summer, and remembered listening to the confused woman behind me complain about the last five minutes of the movie. I had a hard time keeping my eyes open during Wild Tigers I Have Known, and tried watching it again on the IFC Channel a few weeks ago-it still didn't work out.

As for the final list on your page, several of those are getting an abundant amount of praise they don't deserve. Into the Wild, although good and pretty to look at, suffered through Sean Penn's script, which really asked me to care for this chaarcter more than I was able to. Away from Her had good performances, but nothing much after that. Beowulf, once again, had some nice images, but not more than that. I kind of hated Margot at the Wedding, Poison Friends, The Situation, Southland Tales, and Zoo. I enjoyed Before the Devil Knows You're Dead and Rocket Science, but I kind of wish you'd put more stock into 12:08, Jesse James, Jindabyne, and There Will Be Blood. And Planet Terror (incorrectly posted here as Terror Planet) was fun to watch in the context of Grindhouse as a whole (while Death Proof was still the better movie, its that three hour package that I really loved). Not sure how it would work on its own.

I'm grateful for your rather nonplus reaction to Juno-which while I really liked I wouldn't go as far as the mammoth reaction its getting-and I'm Not There, while puzzled me. Like you said, it had something going for it, but its ambition almost overshadowed any attempts to make it good.

There's not much to respond to here, although I will say you probably will give a hearty thumbs down to my list.