Comments on Newspaper Rock: South Dakota = Mississippi of the North

Writerfella here -- That is a danger when one ...

2007-03-04T05:09:00.000-08:00

Writerfella here --
That is a danger when one discusses what is known as personal interpretations of a given area's response to Native problems. No one in this country is enamored of the fact that their existences are owed to what their ancestors did to establish these United States. It all took place...back there, back then, and none of those alive took part in the events expressed. BUT -- there is a debt involved that also is being denied: this country exists because an entire human population was destroyed so that the children and later descendants of their destructors could benefit from the nation of 'freedom' created on the blood, bones, and graves of those who were destroyed. "I had nothing to do with that," is the common response to history and so it is denied, much as "The Holocaust" now finds itself denied by modern Europeans and even some Americans. Let it be known that conquest of these two continents is not over. It will happen again, and those in denial will suffer the same consequences as the Native Americans know as their own past. It is not logical, but it most often is true...
All Best
Russ Bates
'writerfella'

Yes, he probably should've inserted the word "some...

2007-02-27T12:00:00.000-08:00

Yes, he probably should've inserted the word "some" or "many" in front of "white South Dakotans." But I think it's understood. When you generalize, you're referring to a group characteristic that applies to many but not all the people in the group. Generally speaking, that is.

Does Giago make some salient points? Absolutely. B...

2007-02-27T11:34:00.000-08:00

Does Giago make some salient points? Absolutely. But he weakens his own argument when he says "White South Dakotans are still enamored of an editorial..." Anytime you make an emphatic statement about an entire group of people, you lose credibility. He really didn't need to do that to make his larger point about the prevailing cultural and political winds in South Dakota.